Abdullah al Andalusi

UK BIG DEBATE: Can European Human Rights tolerate Sharia and other religious laws?

Written by

Abdullah al Andalusi

in

, , , ,

on

The MDI Debate on whether European Human Rights can tolerate Sharia and other religious laws is now available to watch.

On the 10th of April 2013, a debate was held on whether European Human Rights could incorporate the rights of religions and their practices. A Rabbi, Human Rights Lecturer, Atheist Humanist and a Muslim debated the issue on a panel.|

The initial post-debate review can be read here.

A transcript of the debate will be available soon.

The full video of the exciting debate on Shariah, the intellectual fallacy of Liberalism, European Human Rights, and reality of Liberal Intolerance can be seen below:

Comments

12 responses to “UK BIG DEBATE: Can European Human Rights tolerate Sharia and other religious laws?”

  1. Manny Avatar
    Manny

    As a non-Muslim, would I be allowed to put up a “cigarettes sold here” sign on my front lawn under a Caliphate?

    Like

    Reply
    1. Abdullah al Andalusi Avatar
      Abdullah al Andalusi

      Yes

      Like

      Reply
  2. Manny Avatar
    Manny

    How about a sign that says:
    -beer sold here or
    -marijuana sold here or
    -brothel

    Like

    Reply
    1. Abdullah al Andalusi Avatar
      Abdullah al Andalusi

      In non-Muslim autonomous areas, sure for the first one. Iraq had pig farms during the Caliphates! (amongst Christian areas).

      As for the last two, I’d doubt you could have those signs in most areas of Western ‘free’ countries!

      Like

      Reply
  3. Manny Avatar
    Manny

    So if the majority of non-Muslims living within the non-Muslim autonomous area had not issue with my sign\service, would the Caliphate allow it?

    Like

    Reply
    1. Abdullah al Andalusi Avatar
      Abdullah al Andalusi

      Why would the Caliphate need to allow/not allow something that occurs in a self-governing (Ottoman’s called them millets) autonomous regions? .

      As the Quran says: ‘to you your way, and to me mine’

      Like

      Reply
  4. Manny Avatar
    Manny

    Considering:
    -the transaction would only happen in private space
    -only individuals who consent to service/sale would enter the private space

    Why would the Caliphate not allow me to put up said sign in a Muslim majority area?

    Like

    Reply
    1. Abdullah al Andalusi Avatar
      Abdullah al Andalusi

      Would a Western country allow you to put up the sign ‘cocaine sold here’, ‘as long as you sold it in private’?

      Like

      Reply
  5. Manny Avatar
    Manny

    Yes Mexico.

    Why would the Caliphate not allow me to put up said signs in a Muslim majority area? Is it because it would be just as intolerant as some western countries towards these types of things?

    You did say the Caliphate would not care what people did in private.

    Like

    Reply
    1. Abdullah al Andalusi Avatar
      Abdullah al Andalusi

      Mexico is not a Western country in the traditional sense. Also, you rather miss the obvious. Putting up a sign advertising what you do in your house, is not privacy.

      A Caliphate does not care what people do in private, as long as you keep it private.

      Like

      Reply
  6. Manny Avatar
    Manny

    So Why would the Caliphate not allow me to put up said signs in a Muslim majority area?

    Like

    Reply
    1. Abdullah al Andalusi Avatar
      Abdullah al Andalusi

      Putting up a sign advertising what you do in your house, is not privacy.

      Like

      Reply

Leave a reply to Manny Cancel reply